• About
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Endeavour Awards
  • Sell and Hire
Sunday, January 25, 2026
Newsletter
SUBSCRIBE
MARKETPLACE
  • Latest News
    • Tasmania
    • Victoria
    • ACT
    • New South Wales
    • Queensland
    • Northern Territory
    • South Australia
    • Western Australia
  • All Sections
    • Manufacturing Topics
      • Additive
      • Advanced
      • Compressors
      • Manufacturing Software
      • Defence
      • Sustainability
      • Machine tools
      • Research
      • Materials handling & logistics
      • Raw materials & composites
      • Electrical
    • Technology
      • Industry 4.0
      • 3D printing
      • Laser cutting
      • Robotics & Automation
      • Plastics
      • Prototyping
      • Engineering products
    • Manufacturing Opinion
      • Skills and training
      • Welding
      • Growing sovereign capability
      • Digitalisation
      • Australian Made
      • Research & Development
      • Innovation
    • Manufacturing Experts
      • Australian Manufacturing Growth Centre
      • South East Melbourne Manufacturers Alliance
      • Association for Manufacturing Excellence
      • Weld Australia
      • Australian Industry Group
      • Innovation and Business Skills Australia
      • Innovative Manufacturing CRC
      • SEMMA
  • Manufacturer Focus
  • Resources
    • Whitepapers
    • Webinars
    • Case Studies
    • Products
  • Events
    • Australia
    • International
    • Seminars
    • Endeavour Awards
No Results
View All Results
  • Latest News
    • Tasmania
    • Victoria
    • ACT
    • New South Wales
    • Queensland
    • Northern Territory
    • South Australia
    • Western Australia
  • All Sections
    • Manufacturing Topics
      • Additive
      • Advanced
      • Compressors
      • Manufacturing Software
      • Defence
      • Sustainability
      • Machine tools
      • Research
      • Materials handling & logistics
      • Raw materials & composites
      • Electrical
    • Technology
      • Industry 4.0
      • 3D printing
      • Laser cutting
      • Robotics & Automation
      • Plastics
      • Prototyping
      • Engineering products
    • Manufacturing Opinion
      • Skills and training
      • Welding
      • Growing sovereign capability
      • Digitalisation
      • Australian Made
      • Research & Development
      • Innovation
    • Manufacturing Experts
      • Australian Manufacturing Growth Centre
      • South East Melbourne Manufacturers Alliance
      • Association for Manufacturing Excellence
      • Weld Australia
      • Australian Industry Group
      • Innovation and Business Skills Australia
      • Innovative Manufacturing CRC
      • SEMMA
  • Manufacturer Focus
  • Resources
    • Whitepapers
    • Webinars
    • Case Studies
    • Products
  • Events
    • Australia
    • International
    • Seminars
    • Endeavour Awards
No Results
View All Results
Home

[OPINION] Carbon tax wreckage brings manufacturers together

by Sophie Mirabella
June 15, 2011
in Manufacturing News
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Shadow Minister for Innovation, Industry and Science, Sophie Mirabella MP, writes exclusively for Manufacturers’ Monthly.

For all of the disastrous ramifications of Julia Gillard’s decision to implement a carbon tax, there has at least been one positive consequence to emerge from the wreckage.

I say that because the debate on the tax has graphically reminded Australians of the enduring spirit, passion and commitment of our country’s manufacturers.    

To see, as all of us have done, manufacturing businesses and workers rising up so defiantly against this destructive policy (and doing so in such numbers) has been a moving experience.  

Manufacturers are already feeling frustrated and angry that so many of the existing policy settings continue to operate to the detriment of Australian businesses rather than to their advantage. But those sentiments have become even more intensely felt since the Government adopted a siege mentality and broke its election promise not to introduce a carbon tax.      

Since I became the Shadow Minister for Industry in late 2009, I have been privileged to meet regularly with manufacturers across the length and breadth of the country. But at no time have I sensed such disquiet and disillusionment with the Government’s neglect of manufacturing as in the past three months. 

The refusal of manufacturers to lie down and accept policies that threaten their very existence has been gratifying to anyone who understands how important a strong and viable manufacturing sector is for our economy. 

It has also been heartening in a number of other respects, too – not least because it has helped to sharpen the focus, at the national political level, on the future of manufacturing in Australia. 

It has helped to revive a vital national debate by causing many people to consider critical questions about the kind of economy we want to have in the future. It has also forced them to stop and contemplate what the loss of an indigenous Australian manufacturing capability might mean for us in 10 or 20 years from now.       

Australian manufacturing workers are smart, innovative and hard-working people who know full well what a carbon tax will do to their international competitiveness. Especially in the absence of similar policies being adopted in other countries. 

They also know that the businesses in which they work are already trying to combat a range of pressures. And that the last thing they need right now is to be asked to absorb yet another substantial (and annually escalating) cost, let alone one that won’t be borne by their overseas rivals.     

Whether it’s with car workers in Geelong and Altona, plastics makers in Dandenong, food producers on the Central Coast, steel fabricators in Fremantle or a host of others, these are among the messages that continue to resonate when I meet with manufacturers all around the country. 

Another refrain is that the Government simply doesn’t understand that times are tough, and that Australians are now anxious about their livelihoods and about making ends meet.  

There was already disbelief that our Government was doing so little to help Australian manufacturers. But now there is palpable anger at its attempts to club manufacturing out of existence.  

In the national interest, the Coalition will continue to fight against this industry-destroying and job-destroying tax. And I would urge the same of anyone who wants Australian manufacturing to survive.  

Do you agree with Mirabella that the carbon tax is industry- and job-destroying? Post your comment below, or on Twitter @manmonthly.

 

Premium Ad
6

$66,000

2022 MANITOU MLT630 MLT 630-115 V CP

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Donald, VIC

03 9998 4661
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
22

$69,500

2016 MANITOU 1135H

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
  • » Lift capacity at maximum height - kg: 3,000
  • » Maximum lift height - mm: 7,600
  • » Operating weight - kg: 8,600
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Yatala, QLD

07 3171 1740
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
23

$79,000

2017 JCB 540-140 HI VIS

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
  • » Maximum lift height - mm: 14,000
  • » Operating weight - kg: 11,300
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Dubbo, NSW

02 8315 0022
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
7

$65,450

2005 DIECI DEDALUS 28.7

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Donald, VIC

03 9998 4661
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
5

$13,200

POA

(HIRE)

PRENTICE 7,000KG SWL

  • » Listing Type: Used
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Granville, NSW

1800 688 788
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
10

$86,900

2013 MANITOU MLT X 735 MLT-X735 T LSU

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
  • » Operating weight - kg: 7,275
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Donald, VIC

03 9998 4661
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
11

$104,500

2019 MANITOU MLAT 533

  • » Listing Type: Used
  • » Class: General Spec
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Toowoomba, QLD

07 3171 1832
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
20

POA

2025 MAGNI TH 7.10P

  • » Listing Type: New
  • » Class: General Spec
  • » Maximum lift height - mm: 10,000
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Henderson, WA

08 6555 0978
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
14

POA

DINGLI BT28RT

  • » Listing Type: Used
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Henderson, WA

08 6555 0978
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
8

POA

XCMG MATERIAL HANDLER XE480WGM - AVAILABLE NOW IN AUSTRALIA

  • » Listing Type: New
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Maddington, WA

08 6500 0940
MORE DETAILS
Premium Ad
6

POA

2025 MAGNI TH 3.6

  • » Listing Type: New
  • » Class: General Spec
  • » Maximum lift height - mm: 6,000
Location marker The shape of a location marker

Henderson, WA

08 6555 0978
MORE DETAILS
3

$1,749

SUREWELD 3.5M, 300KG CAPACITY (79CM WIDTH) CLIMAXX WALK BOARD SERIES LOADING RAMP

  • » Listing Type: New
Location marker The shape of a location marker
Delivery Australia Wide
07 3085 2777
MORE DETAILS

Related Posts

Image: AMCL

New $20M government-backed ‘Made Right Here’ campaign

by Jack Lloyd
January 23, 2026

Australian Made Campaign Ltd (AMCL) today unveiled its largest national advertising campaign encouraging Australians to support local manufacturers, job creation...

Image: RMIT University

New carbon-conversion technology could turn emissions into jet fuel

by Jack Lloyd
January 23, 2026

RMIT researchers have developed a carbon‑conversion technology that may one day help turn industrial emissions into jet fuel, by simplifying...

Image: AMCL

New $20M government-backed ‘Made Right Here’ campaign to launch

by Jack Lloyd
January 23, 2026

Australian Made Campaign Ltd (AMCL) will today unveil the ‘Made Right Here’ campaign, its largest national advertising campaign aimed at...

Join our newsletter

View our privacy policy, collection notice and terms and conditions to understand how we use your personal information.
Manufacturers’ Monthly is a business-to-business magazine and a valuable reference tool for all members of the manufacturing industry. The magazine is highly targeted and is read by key decision-makers who purchase and specify manufacturing equipment and services. It is also widely read by suppliers to the manufacturing industry.

Subscribe to our newsletter

View our privacy policy, collection notice and terms and conditions to understand how we use your personal information.

About Us

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Collection Notice
  • Privacy Policy

Popular Topics

  • Manufacturing News
  • Features
  • Magazine
  • Endeavour Awards
  • Whitepapers
  • Webinars
  • Case Studies
  • Videos on Demand

Our TraderAds Network

  • Arbor Age
  • Australian Car Mechanic
  • Australian Mining
  • Australian Resources & Investment
  • Big Rigs
  • Bulk Handling Review
  • Bus News
  • Cranes & Lifting
  • Earthmoving Equipment Magazine
  • EcoGeneration
  • Energy Today
  • Food & Beverage
  • Fully Loaded
  • Global Trailer
  • Inside Construction
  • Inside Waste
  • Inside Water
  • Landscape Contractor Magazine
  • Manufacturers' Monthly
  • MHD Supply Chain
  • National Collision Repairer
  • OwnerDriver
  • Power Torque
  • Prime Mover Magazine
  • Quarry
  • Roads Online
  • Rail Express
  • Safe To Work
  • The Australian Pipeliner
  • Trade Earthmovers
  • Trade Farm Machinery
  • Trade Plant Equipment
  • Trade Trucks
  • Trade Unique Cars
  • Tradie Magazine
  • Trailer Magazine
  • Trenchless Australasia
  • Waste Management Review

© 2026 All Rights Reserved. All content published on this site is the property of Prime Creative Media. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited

No Results
View All Results
NEWSLETTER
SUBSCRIBE
MARKETPLACE
  • Latest News
  • All Sections
    • Manufacturing Topics
      • Additive
      • Advanced
      • Compressors
      • Manufacturing Software
      • Defence
      • Sustainability
      • Machine tools
      • Research
      • Materials handling & logistics
      • Raw materials & composites
      • Electrical
    • Technology
      • Industry 4.0
      • 3D printing
      • Laser cutting
      • Robotics & Automation
      • Plastics
      • Prototyping
      • Engineering products
    • Manufacturing Opinion
      • Skills and training
      • Welding
      • Growing sovereign capability
      • Digitalisation
      • Australian Made
      • Research & Development
      • Innovation
    • Manufacturing Experts
      • Australian Manufacturing Growth Centre
      • South East Melbourne Manufacturers Alliance
      • Association for Manufacturing Excellence
      • Weld Australia
      • Australian Industry Group
      • Innovation and Business Skills Australia
      • Innovative Manufacturing CRC
  • Resources
    • Whitepapers
    • Products
    • Webinars
    • Case Studies
  • Events
    • Australia
    • International
    • Seminars
    • Endeavour Awards
  • Endeavour Awards
  • Marketplace
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • List Stock

© 2026 All Rights Reserved. All content published on this site is the property of Prime Creative Media. Unauthorised reproduction is prohibited